In soccer, Grace was named to Colonial Council 1st Team twice, Colonial Council 2nd Team, and a 2x Section II Class B All Star. In basketball, she was a 1000 point scorer, a 3x Class A All-Star, named Colonial Council 1st Team three times and was a Colonial Council Top Scholar Athlete, and was named Best Teammate and Team MVP three times (AHN). She was named 2018 & 2019 team MVP (AHN) in lacrosse.